George Martinez
Sociology 88S
T.A Eric Kim
3 June 2010
Breaking Barriers: How the Internet Has Done More Than Bring Us Closer
The internet has greatly changed the lives of many people since it is a central, necessary part of everyday life. People now not only use the internet for the purpose of email, but as the world stands in 2010, the internet has also expanded to include digital methods to shop, video chat, call, watch television, movies, and do an assortment of other things that would impossible 20 years ago. By increasing the speed and efficiency in which people communicate, the Internet has pushed people closer together by providing a means for people to more easily connect with each other. Over the course of the spring quarter, the readings and experiments on topics like online self presentation, privacy paradoxes social capital arising from online networking, and possible changes coming to the way we communicate have allowed me to see how the internet has already changed the way we function as a society. By getting closer to each other and having more control over the image we send out of ourselves, the Internet has become a tool through which an easier connection brings a mixed bag of results, since bringing people closer together can lead to unintended consequences.
The identity construction experiment allowed me to see how easier communication can lead to false identity creation. When people do not have to be held to the same degree of honor as they would offline, this can create an opportunity for a person to lie about the kind of person that they actually are. In experiment three, I was told to create a persona that was different from my personal identity. So instead of being a twenty year old Hispanic male, I pretended to be a sixteen year old Asian-American female to another online person (Experiment 3). By using common stereotypes such as being a bad driver and having a strict father, I was able to convince the other person that the Asian identity was in fact who I am. As stated by Charles Chung, I was using Goffman’s concept of “impression management” to give off the identity of someone else (Cheung 312). By allowing two random strangers to chat and perhaps not even be honest about them over Omegle, the Internet allows us to be closer yet also be able to create new lies. Bringing people closer together can do more than allow people to create a false identity; it can also create the unintended consequence of greater access to personal information.
Online privacy has also arisen from the internet as a result of the greater interconnectedness of online information. In week seven’s experiment, for example, I was asked to go through a classmate’s Facebook information and gain as much personal information as I could from them, and to my surprise, the classmate had so little information compared to the majority of Facebook users that I know (Experiment 7). Yet, even with this little information I was able to gain information on his birthday, hometown, school, and full name. With such little information, one could potentially do a background search on the person to literally know their whole life story. Therefore, one drawback to the internet bringing us closer together is that one’s personal information could be used against oneself, based on a few simple facts from one’s Facebook. There still no real solutions preventing the misuse of personal misinformation, which means that, this greater interconnectedness can be misused on the basis of a few facts.
However, on the positive side, week six’s author allows us to see how more online friends allow one to build up “social capital” (Ellison 1148). Online networks such as Facebook have allowed me to keep in touch with many people whom I cannot easily see often. By having access to a live feed where everyone’s status updates appear, I have easier access to more people’s lives. Therefore, I have a greater chance of keeping a “maintained social capital” (Ellison 1148). Maintained social capital has been linked to better public health. Therefore, it makes sense that I feel like I have not personally lost friends that I have seen in a while such as high school since the Internet allows me to have easier access and more social capital (Ellison 1145). Thus, while the Internet brings us closer to other people’s personal information, it can also help maintain social capital.
Week ten’s reading allows an interesting analysis of the type of networks that may develop from current social network sites. At the moment, the Internet brings us closer together by allowing us to maintain ties through social network sites. However, what makes this interesting is that we might be able to use social networking sites to influence public life by putting “place awareness and mobility” together (Ellison 8). For example, we might be able to blur the lines between online and offline interactions by using phones that allow us to see where are friends are by simply looking at one’s phone (Ellison 8). One positive aspect of this is that, if this trend comes true, planning events can have both online and offline aspects to it. Once again, the Internet bringing people closer together has created more efficient ways of getting stuff done by allowing for easier ways of knowing when and where people are.
Looking back at the quarter’s work, the internet bringing people closer together allows a greater degree of personal freedom in some areas , while at the same time, it decrease personal freedom in other areas. It is not so much a question of if the internet brings us closer as much as it is to what people do with a greater interconnectedness that the internet brings as it evolves. In some positive aspects, yes, we can keep in contact with friends with much less effort, but at the same time, people can misuse our personal information and pretend to be another identity entirely. To say that there is one clear-cut solution to the misuse of identity or personal information would mean risk rolling back on the positives that the internet has brought to us as it has brought us closer. Only time will tell which degree of personal freedom will ultimately prevail.
Works Cited
Cheung, “Identity Construction and Self-Presentation on Personal Homepages” (POR IV, pg. 310-320).
Ellison, N. B., Steinfield, C., & Lampe, C. (2007). The Benefits of Facebook “Friends:” Social Capital and College Students’ Use of Online Social Network Sites. Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication, (pg. 1145-1148, pg. 1153-1165).
Ellison, N. B., Steinfield, C., & Lampe, C. (2009). Social Network Sites and Society: Current Trends and Future Possibilities. Interactions. (Pg. 6-9)
“Week Three Experiment: Chatting with a Random Stranger Online”
“Week Seven Experiment: Viewing a Classmate’s Facebook”